| Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | rawtwins | 4/12/12 4:09 AM | Hello, youtube enhancer is pretty good, you can stabilise or cut videos, I use it pretty often, but still one very important feature is missing - Noise Reduction. I think everybody would love it, it would save a lot of energy for ppl to do it manuall |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | ebbixx | 4/12/12 4:16 AM | It's an interesting suggestion and I hope they consider it. One block may be, however, that the most popular form of noise reduction, Dolby, is still patented unless I'm mistaken and may require licensing, a sort of licence that is fairly easy and ch |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | JDoors | 4/12/12 4:47 AM | I 'third' that suggestion. Sounds like it would be a no-brainer to add to the editing tools. |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | gbcali | 4/12/12 5:10 AM | @rawtwins– Audio Noise Reduction or Video Noise Reduction ? |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | rawtwins | 4/12/12 9:53 PM | Audio Noise Reduction |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | Tyler Dehan | 4/13/12 3:58 AM | Automated noise reduction has a large margin for error, and if it picks the wrong part of the video to sample for "noise", the audio will sound abhorrent. Another solution would be to have the user pick a portion of audio to sample. But if you're goi |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | JDoors | 4/13/12 4:45 AM | You never really know what the video is going to look or sound like until after you've taken the time to upload it. YouTube could mangle it in any of a number of different ways. Having the option to minimize some extraneous noise would be a good opti |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | rawtwins | 4/13/12 11:44 AM | I don't recommened automatic noise reduction, I guess it isn't so hard for user to pick a pure noise. Then also code would be more simple I guess. Or both options :) Why I wouldn't do that by myself before upload? Well why is there any Youtube editor |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | ebbixx | 4/13/12 1:03 PM | A good and very valid comment. But given the unpredictability of YouTube audio processing, as Devil's Advocate I'd ask, why would you trust them to do the noise reduction any better? I'm actually asking this because I'm in the middle of rethinking my |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | ebbixx | 4/13/12 1:06 PM | Good reminder that both options are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Even the most competent among us might be put in a situation where we needed to tweak something after the fact, and being able to do than on YouTube itself would actually perhaps |
| Re: Please add Noise Reduction feature to youtube editor/enhance | JDoors | 4/13/12 1:43 PM | Heh-heh, good point. They may screw up your audio, and then, ironically, offer audio processing. But they offer other types of processing that do not work 100% of the time, so a noise reduction option that may or may not work wouldn't be a stretch. |