Now I'm really confused. I just received another Suspected Hacking email after cleaning the site and requesting reconsideration.
I've done a site:hawkfeather.com search and checked every page listed. Google still had a few pages cached with bad content, including a few with redirects. I checked those with both View Source and Fetch as Googlebot and saw nothing. So I resubmitted those.
SafeBrowsing says nothing's listed. No malware reported. Htaccess is fine. Nothing suspicious in the logs. diff on files/dirs show no changes since repair.