| "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
eeplox |
2/24/12 9:45 AM |
I posted a video which is basically just me walking and talking, outdoors, away from any possible source of music. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nPBlfeuZuWg And apparently youtube identified my video as containing copyrighted music from a company c |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/24/12 3:03 PM |
NO! It is a very common occurrence. It is a well-known error. One person has had to file over 100 disputes for mistaken bird sounds. For some reason Google is reluctant to fix this so companies like rumblefish take advantage of it to gain fraudulent |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
eeplox |
2/24/12 9:57 PM |
Thanks for the help. This is what it says: All content owners have reviewed your video and confirmed their claims to some or all of its content: - Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/25/12 12:04 AM |
Well then, that was a quick review (and confirmation). Most likely they don’t have a clue what’s in your video. Google gives them what was matched and where it occurred in you video but they obviously didn’t check. Google is finished at this point so |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/25/12 12:16 AM |
P.S. This illustrates a couple of my pet peeves about this process. Google hides the notification by only changing the wording on the notice but gives you no way to know that other than to check periodically. At least this was fast. I sometime have t |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Bior |
2/26/12 2:34 PM |
This is outrageous. Rumblefish should get punished for false copyright claims. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
FormerGogleFan |
2/26/12 5:24 PM |
Google could do something about this, but they clearly don't care. That is evil. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markzmen101 |
2/26/12 5:30 PM |
Wow, these claimers are real terrorizing perpetrators. The bizarre thing is that someone would actually consider such self-centered egoism in respect of a law. Shows one how laws are to be twisted. SOPA lovers beware. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
clevershark |
2/26/12 5:53 PM |
Google tips the balance towards the copyright claimants regardless of whether the claims are valid or not that I just won't post anything to Youtube anymore and instead have chosen an alternate video host who isn't so willing to throw its users under |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
clevershark |
2/26/12 5:54 PM |
Incidentally it's difficult for me to imagine why Google and its subsidiaries are against SOPA as they have themselves fully adopted SOPA's "shoot first and ask questions never" attitude towards copyright claims no matter how dodgy they are... |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
eightyape |
2/26/12 5:57 PM |
welcome to future of the internet |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Zisteau |
2/26/12 6:06 PM |
Rumblefish cost me several hundred dollars in ad revenue because of this very issue. They're slimy thugs abusing the system. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Nothingness |
2/26/12 6:09 PM |
I would be contacted every medium found on this page: http://rumblefish.com/about-us.php#tabs-6 |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
DanChorley |
2/26/12 6:16 PM |
That's absolutely pathetic, I agree completely with Bior, they should definitely be punished - their rights to remove content should be restricted, or their requests should be moderated by someone at YouTube before content is actually removed. This j |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
enantiomer2000 |
2/26/12 6:22 PM |
Shame on you Google. I am throwing away my Android phone and going down town to buy myself an iPhone! |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Wuggyboobeaufuf |
2/26/12 6:34 PM |
Google and Youtube should be forced to pay $1000 every time a false claim is abused like this. Rumblefish should be barred from making any copyright claims at all. EEplox should sue both their asses. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
edmartech |
2/26/12 6:36 PM |
I experienced this in one of my videos. My video has no background music at all. Just my voice. The complaint is not from Rumblefish though, it is from Music Publishing Rights Collecting Society. As you can see, it is a generic name. I believe that t |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
jrbrewin |
2/26/12 6:39 PM |
I'm interested in learning how Rumblefish were able to automatically detect bird song, or your voice and claim it as their own. Have they somehow fingerprinted bird song with google, and all videos with song from a particular breed of bird are automa |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
PoisonSnow |
2/26/12 6:42 PM |
I have had three videos that have been TAKEN DOWN because an external site has uploaded them. This is getting out of hand... |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
RHStevens |
2/26/12 6:52 PM |
Wow, this is crap. This whole strategy of pulling content and THEN having to petition for its legal and legitimate return is RIDICULOUS. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
fraize |
2/26/12 7:23 PM |
People. It's not Google. It's DMCA. Google is merely following the law. Blame the law. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Russell VT |
2/26/12 7:30 PM |
According to their FAQ ( http://rumblefish.com/id/youtube-content-id.php), it's possible for the to mis-identify their copyrighted material (it's an automated process). Their website indicates they'll take queries at: YouTubeC...@rumblefish.com |
|
(unknown) |
2/26/12 7:30 PM |
<This message has been deleted.> |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
shayne oneill |
2/26/12 7:31 PM |
I should note filing fradulent copyright claims is actually illegal, not in the civil, but in the criminal, sense in most countries. (Its something like a 3 year prison term here in australia). Google, you actually need to put a human onto investiga |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
sc34 |
2/26/12 7:38 PM |
Hi eeplox, You should consult the help files which are available here: https://www.google.com/adsense/support/?sourceid=asos&subid=ww-ww-et-u2u_breadcrumb&medium=link Should you require any further assistance contact Google support here: https://sup |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
mr5rockhopper4 |
2/26/12 7:52 PM |
Just came here from Reddit, and I agree, this is incredible. I think that if someone makes so many false copyright claims, they should loose their privileges of that copyright, and prevented from copyrighting that particular thing. |
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
ehrensw |
2/26/12 8:02 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
BajaChepe |
2/26/12 8:05 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/26/12 8:15 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
GarretMH |
2/26/12 8:35 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
John-Dee |
2/26/12 8:47 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Zeraliten |
2/26/12 8:51 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
MrOrientalOccidental |
2/26/12 9:58 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Parabola949 |
2/26/12 10:37 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Anti-X |
2/26/12 10:59 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/26/12 11:10 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
simoncpu |
2/26/12 11:20 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
JPizzle1122 |
2/27/12 12:16 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
MrOrientalOccidental |
2/27/12 12:34 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
gwebmaster |
2/27/12 4:04 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Xyzwao |
2/27/12 4:18 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
mbtria |
2/27/12 6:06 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
leon.san.email |
2/27/12 6:35 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
billjaber |
2/27/12 7:23 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
geoffrey g |
2/27/12 8:18 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
apurvasukant |
2/27/12 8:46 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/27/12 9:49 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Simbamatic |
2/27/12 10:22 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
nskinsella |
2/27/12 10:33 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Gudsine |
2/27/12 12:08 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Linuxluver |
2/27/12 12:36 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Linuxluver |
2/27/12 12:39 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/27/12 1:00 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
RF-Josh |
2/27/12 1:23 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
jcobia |
2/27/12 5:18 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
2/27/12 7:29 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
ScottKin |
2/27/12 11:58 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
getouterherez |
2/28/12 5:52 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Libertina |
2/28/12 8:05 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
eeplox |
2/29/12 12:28 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
JuryDutySummons |
2/29/12 12:26 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
youtubenation |
3/1/12 3:17 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
gbcali |
3/1/12 6:10 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
rnickeymouse |
3/1/12 7:29 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
3/1/12 12:20 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
rnickeymouse |
3/1/12 7:25 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
KactuX |
3/2/12 2:56 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
richardhead |
3/3/12 1:30 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
PhantomSafetyPin |
3/3/12 5:12 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
durhamtelly |
3/19/12 4:39 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
sareis7 |
3/27/12 9:43 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
durhamtelly |
3/28/12 1:07 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
markimatang |
3/28/12 10:24 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
AGrandt |
3/30/12 12:45 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
clemenzina |
4/1/12 6:37 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
Linuxluver |
10/1/12 2:52 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
JimZubemo |
11/21/12 8:55 AM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
JeremyShaferOrigami |
12/27/12 10:33 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
JeremyShaferOrigami |
12/27/12 10:35 PM |
|
| Re: "Matched third party content. Entity: rumblefish Content Type: Musical Composition", but no music in the video |
billel chinwi |
1/2/13 10:20 AM |
|