| Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | gguillotte | 4/18/11 5:03 PM | If an item is shared by me or one of my friends, and it doesn't already have comments on it, I can't comment on it. My friends also cannot comment on it. Checking the item in Firebug, I can see this HTML: ... <div class="entry-body"><div><div class |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | vile_wench | 4/18/11 5:37 PM | I am also having this problem. Chrome 10 (OS X) and Firefox 3 (OS X) |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | AmyJohn7 | 4/18/11 5:38 PM | I am also having this problem on multiple computers with Firefox 3.6.16 as described above. Commenting was working this morning, but around 2pm CST the comment button disappeared from shared feeds. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | meshroom | 4/18/11 5:44 PM | Not working for me either. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Martini-Corona | 4/18/11 5:57 PM | Not working for me on FF4/Mac. Worked earlier today on a different Mac using FF3. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | plainclothedman | 4/18/11 6:16 PM | Same thing for me both in Chrome and on my phone. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | kudzuplanet | 4/18/11 6:16 PM | Not working on Mac, Firefox for me, or for my friends on Windows. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | AnnieBlue | 4/18/11 6:20 PM | I am having the same problem as are most of the friends with whom I share feeds. This is problem on Firefox 4 and the latest version of Chrome, on both a Windows XP computer and a Windows 7 computer. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | mwhybark | 4/18/11 6:42 PM | ditto FF 3.x Mac 10.6.7 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | mlpatten | 4/18/11 7:14 PM | Same here, on a Mac with Firefox 3 or Safari 4. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Fieldtini | 4/18/11 7:28 PM | Same here, FF4. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | mahmoud.hashemi | 4/18/11 7:47 PM | I'll chime in and say I'm facing this same issue and it's killin me, bros. (Chrome 10, 11) |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | damien.galban | 4/19/11 12:49 AM | Same here, and for at least 3 people in my office too. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Ali S | 4/19/11 12:53 AM | Me too. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Raja Kajiev | 4/19/11 3:46 AM | +1 Win7/FF4 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Darth Medved | 4/19/11 4:12 AM | Win Vista/Chrome 10.0 - NOKWin Vista/FF4 - NOKWin Vista/Opera 11.10 - NOK |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | nviola | 4/19/11 4:14 AM | Looks like they disabled the comments on Reader...Win XP SP3/Chrome 10 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | klaasjanelzinga | 4/19/11 5:21 AM | +1 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | fotomaf | 4/19/11 5:24 AM | :( |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Moo | 4/19/11 5:35 AM | +1 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | j0hnjac | 4/19/11 5:36 AM | +1 Chrome 12 on OS X. Current workaround for me is to use BUZZ in GMail to get the 1st comment on the shared item. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | gguillotte | 4/19/11 5:43 AM | @j0hnjac: Thanks for checking that. Buzz won't work for those of us with no Google Profiles (incl. me) but that should help most people. |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | CilindroX | 4/19/11 5:47 AM | +1 FF4-Chrome Ubuntu Maverick / FF4 Win7 |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | gguillotte | 4/19/11 5:51 AM | Multiple reports in my Reader party that posting first comments is working again, but only on newly shared items. I reproduced in Chrome 10 and FF4. There was no notice in the app that Reader was updated. Steps to reproduce:* Refresh the Google Read |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | gguillotte | 4/19/11 5:59 AM | There's still issues with items shared with notes, items shared via the "Note in Reader" bookmarklet, and items shared while commenting was broken. The workaround to activate comments is to unshare them (click the "Unshare" link), then reshare them ( |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | The Nerd | 4/19/11 6:02 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | gguillotte | 4/19/11 6:15 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | devondoane | 4/19/11 6:56 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | KWIntellogist | 4/19/11 7:01 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Mihai P. | 4/19/11 7:44 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | GeorgeKaplan | 4/19/11 9:41 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Mihai P. | 4/19/11 9:47 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | m.f.mahyarsoft | 4/19/11 10:54 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | jasonchapman | 4/19/11 11:34 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | focalpoint | 4/19/11 3:40 PM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Mihai P. | 4/19/11 9:27 PM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Moo | 4/19/11 10:34 PM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | damien.galban | 4/19/11 11:58 PM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Fernando12 | 4/20/11 6:17 AM | |
| Re: Can't comment on items unless they already have comments on them | Lemanie | 5/6/11 12:48 PM |